Royal Charter
The MCC Committee, in response to Member concerns, decided it was time more than a decade ago to incorporate the Club so it was no longer a Private Member Club likely to attract any potential unlimited financial liabilities for the Membership in the future. The MCC Royal Charter Petition was approved at SGM by MCC Members on 25th June 2012 by a majority of 6018 votes and granted on 12th December 2012.
The Committee considered this to be a unique opportunity to end an outdated system of arbitrary government first introduced in 1787 and replace it with a pre-eminent form of modern democratic government with a history of Royal Patronage. This would be a fitting tribute to a Club whose roots date back to the Royal Family and a donation made by the Prince of Wales in1866 when Lord’s was purchased by MCC. Later on the Duke of Edinburgh enjoyed a record two terms as the Club President.
Problems
On 1st July 2013 the Royal Charter became effective with a similar set of Rules operating as before.
Learned Counsel specialising in the implementation of Royal Charters states in his Opinion:- “A Royal Charter exists as a dormant shell only. It can only start to operate once the undertaking and assets (plus any liabilities, where appropriate) of the unincorporated form of the MCC have transferred to it. It seems that a key part of that exercise will be to ensure that the MCC’s Membership transfers to the one Body Corporate – something that might usually be undertaken at the point of subscription renewal”. Members have not been notified of any change in their Subscription payments that continue to be levied and paid into the same MCC Bank Account .
The implications here are serious with the fact that no comprehensive restructuring has taken place and the MCC Committee must remain culpable:- 1) the status of Lord’s Cricket Ground is uncertain and open to potential execution (ISWP) 2) the status and role of the Club Trustees remain undetermined (ISWP) 3) no form of democratic government requiring Member approval at SGM, is in place to fulfil the requirements of a pre-eminent democratic Royal Charter Incorporation.
Resolution
The MCC Committee needs to publish a ROYAL CHARTER CONSULTATION GREEN PAPER without delay and instruct a Special Working Party (SWP) to oversee the necessary changes to determine the final incorporation and governance structure of MCC to maximise the annual income from the Lord’s Estate and enhance Member rights and privileges at Lord’s.
Richard Bramwell QC ( 22 September 2006) recommended two subsidiary companies “MCC Property”and “MCC Commercial” should become upon incorporation wholly-owned subsidiaries. No action has been taken.
Proposal
To Chairman MCC
Dear Mark,
Following the rejection of our request to supply the necessary Forms to instruct the Committee to requisition an SGM in accordance with Rule 23.1 (i) we wish to remind you of your duty of care as the Chair MCC (Rule 9.2).
Counsel’s Opinion is clear, the MCC Committee is appointed by the Members as their Agent and the Committee does not enjoy unfettered executive powers of management – democracy and the rule of law remain sovereign within one Body Corporate to which all MCC Members should have been transferred and the private member club status brought to an end long ago.
We wish to draw your attention to the fact the Royal Charter incorporation process that began at SGM on 25th June 2012 remains to be completed with one Body Corporate status being approved by MCC Members at SGM (ref. Royal Charter Articles 1) and 4(c).
It is true that forming the MCC Charter Body is not, alone, sufficient to complete an Incorporation – it is necessary to transfer assets memberships etc. across from the former unincorporated body, the private member club. All 18,000 + MCC members continue to remain today within the domain of the private member club. The “one Body Corporate ” (MCC RC Article 1) remains to be properly constituted and approved by the MCC Members at SGM.
Please confirm you will instruct the MCC Committee to complete the process of Royal Charter Incorporation that began on 12 December 2012 to be completed with Member approval on or before 6th. May 2026.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
Nigel Knott (Dr) Member No 27839
20 January 2025